Heat pump or electric storage hot water?
When an old cylinder fails, most Rowville households end up choosing between a new electric storage unit and a heat pump. Here is how they compare.
How each works
Electric storage heats water with an element inside an insulated tank. It is simple, familiar and quick to replace like for like.
A heat pump pulls heat out of the outdoor air with a fan and compressor and moves it into the tank, working on the same principle as a reverse-cycle split system. It uses much less electricity to heat the same amount of water.
Running costs
This is the biggest difference. A heat pump typically uses around a quarter to a third of the electricity of a standard electric storage system. For a busy Rowville family with two or three bathrooms, the savings over a year can be significant.
Electric storage on an off-peak tariff is cheaper to run than on a general tariff, but still costs more than a heat pump.
Upfront cost
Electric storage cylinders cost less to buy and install. Heat pumps cost more upfront, but rebates and incentives can narrow the gap considerably. Over the life of the system, a heat pump usually works out cheaper because of the lower running costs.
Space and position
Both need a level base and access for servicing. A heat pump also needs airflow around it and should be positioned with noise in mind. Most Rowville homes have a side passage or a corner of the yard that works well. An electric cylinder can go in tighter spaces, including indoors in some cases.
Noise
Electric storage is silent apart from the occasional click. A heat pump makes a low hum while heating, similar to an air conditioner. Placing it away from bedroom windows and using daytime heating settings keeps noise to a minimum.
Performance in winter
Heat pumps work harder in cold weather and take longer to heat the tank, but a correctly sized unit still supplies plenty of hot water through a Melbourne winter. Many models have a backup element for very cold conditions.
Rebates
Heat pumps often qualify for Victorian Government and federal incentives. Electric storage generally does not. Eligibility changes from time to time, so check what applies when you are ready to buy.
Which suits you?
A heat pump may suit you if:
- You plan to stay in the home for several years
- Your household uses a lot of hot water
- You have space with airflow outside
- You want lower running costs and to make use of rebates
Electric storage may suit you if:
- You need the quickest possible replacement
- Space is very limited
- You are planning to sell soon
- Hot water use is low
Getting advice
We are happy to quote on both so you can compare. See heat pump hot water and hot water replacement, or ring 03 9088 0246.
Send us the details
Tell us about the job and a licensed Rowville plumber will ring you back. For a flood, a burst pipe or an overflowing sewer, skip the form and ring 03 9088 0246.
We do not publish a price list, because no two jobs are the same. You will know the cost before any work begins.
More guides
Plumbing problem in Rowville?
Talk to a licensed local plumber today. You will know what is wrong and what it costs before we start.